5 Delicious Pizza Places in Hilton Head Island (2023)

Best Pizza in Hilton Head Island, SC Graphic

Although you may think of seafood when you think of South Carolina, you’d be surprised to know there are some gems that bring in pizza lovers from all near and far. Whether you’re looking for New York-style pizza or authentic Italian, you’ll find delicious pizza options in Hilton Head Island, SC. In this article, I’ll give you a list of the 5 best pizza places in Hilton Head Island and what makes them so special!

Some of the top-rated pizza joints in Hilton Head Island are Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta House, Fat Baby’s Pizza and Subs, and Dough Boys Pizza. Keep following along to learn more. 

Quick Table of 5 Best Pizza Places in Hilton Head

PriceWebsite RatingStand-out Feature 
Guiseppe’s Pizza and Pasta House$$Link Here 4.5 of 5 stars(4.3)
/1,960+ Google reviews
Best Pizza Overall
Il Carpaccio Ristorante$$Link Here4 of 5 Stars(4.2)
/420+_ Google reviews
Best Authentic Italian
Local Pie$$Link Here 4.5 of 5 stars(4.3)
/810+ Google reviews
Best Locally Sourced Ingredients
Fat Baby’s Pizza and Subs$Link Here 4.5 of 5 stars(4.4)
/1,190+ Google reviews
Best Classic Pizza Joint Atmosphere 
Dough Boys $Link Here 4.5 of 5 stars (4.5)
/810+ Google reviews
Best Specialty Pizzas

List of Best Pizza in Hilton Head Island, SC

Woman eating pizza at a restaurant

Hilton Head Island is one of the most popular tourist destinations in the South. Visitors come from all over the world to enjoy things like:

Hilton Head Island is known for its top-of-the-line food and pizza is no exception. The island is home to a few amazing pizzerias that serve up quality pizza. Let’s dive into the list below! 

1. Guiseppe’s Pizza and Pasta House 

Guiseppe’s Pizza and Pasta House is a local favorite in Hilton Head!

Background Info: Their inspiration came from the owner’s favorite neighborhood pizzerias in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania that used fresh ingredients and “cut no corners” when it came to a delicious pizza. 

The Pizza: Guiseppe’s pizza sauce is made fresh from California tomatoes, and pizza dough is made daily at the Bluffton and Hilton Head locations. I have a feeling these extra steps are what make this such great pizza.

Awards: In fact, Lowcountry Style & Living recently named Guiseppe’s Pizza and Pasta House “The Best Pizza on Hilton Head.” And the Reader’s Choice gave it the “Best Pizza” Award from The Island Packet newspaper. 

If you want to wash down your pizza, Guiseppe’s also has a full bar with 16 draft beers.

And if you don’t have time to sit down, delivery, takeout, and take-and-bake pizzas are also available.

Location: 50 Shelter Cove Ln, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

2. II Carpaccio Ristorante

Il Carpaccio is the real deal when it comes to authentic Italian wood-fired pizza.

About: The co-owner of the restaurant comes from a small town outside of Venice, Italy. The legend of Carpaccio is that of a painter from the Renaissance era known for his use of reds and whites. This translated into a famous dish at Harry’s Bar in Venice. 

Highlights: This is the perfect place to enjoy a local, “mom and pop” style dinner. On the menu, you’ll find plenty of delicious options such as ziti, gnocchi, and traditional pizzas. The thin-crust pies are made with fresh mozzarella cheese and a flavorful sauce that transports you straight to Italy. 

Location: 200A Museum St, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926

3. Local Pie 

Cooked pizzas at pizzeria

When it comes to awesome pizza, Local Pie is no stranger.

About: This restaurant serves a true Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizza. They take “local” to its most basic meaning by cooking with the highest quality, regionally-sourced ingredients.

Local Pie also prides itself on being part of the Hilton Head community by being a local business, with local staff, and local suppliers.

Experience: You can build your own pizza, choosing the sauce, cheese, and the traditional toppings such as green peppers, jalapeños, pepperoni, Italian sausage, and many more. Or, try one of their specialty pizzas!

A fan favorite is the Local Margarita Pizza, made with house pecan pesto, mozzarella, tomatoes, house mozzarella, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil. 

Other Menu Items: If you’re not in the mood for pizza, Local Pie also offers some killer menu items such as:

  • the spinach salad
  • delicious wings
  • and fresh baked subs

Location: 55 New Orleans Rd UNIT 106, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

4. Fat Baby’s Pizza and Subs

If you’re looking for a true local spot for good pizza on Hilton Head Island, look no further than Fat Baby’s Pizza and Subs.

About: Modeled after the classic pizza joints of the 1970s, Fat Baby’s is famous for its homeade pies with extra love. Locals and visitors alike love “The Fat Baby,” which comes with pepperoni, sausage, meatball, onion, green bell peppers, black olives, mushrooms, and extra cheese.

While most customers dine in, takeout and delivery are also available at Fat Baby’s. 

Location: 1034 William Hilton Pkwy, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

5. Dough Boys Pizza 

Dough Boys Pizza is the final recommendation on this list and is locally loved.

About: If you ask anyone who lives on the island, they’ll probably tell you that Dough Boys is one of their favorite places for excellent pizza. In fact, Dough Boys is so popular they usually sell out on Friday and Saturday nights, so place your orders early.

The restaurant offers a variety of specialty pizzas, one even has barbecue sauce as the base! 

The Dough Boys restaurant has limited seating, but they accept take-out orders and have the best pizza delivery island-wide. 

Location: 1 New Orleans Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

Summary to Best Pizza Hilton Head

Pizzas cooking in wood burning oven

Hilton Head Island is known for being a tourist destination, especially in the summer. You can find art galleries, breathtaking beaches, and beautiful golf courses. Also, you can also find great restaurants, including classic pizza joints. 

Whether you’re a visitor or a local, you’re sure to find delicious pizza in Hilton Head. Some of my favorites are Fat Baby’s Pizza and Subs, Dough Boys Pizza, and Guisseppe’s Pizza and Pasta House. At these restaurants, you’ll find high-quality food that includes house-made pies with locally sourced, fresh ingredients. 

Planning a vacation to Hilton Head Island area? Check out these other articles on RV parks to stay at and which beaches to visit while you’re there. And if you visit Augusta, here are the top pizza places to check out.

Additional Idea: Try making pizza at home from scratch

The essentials include a pizza stone and wooden pizza scraper; a professional pizza cutter; and a great cookbook for recipe ideas. You can find these over on Amazon.

Also, if you ever want to make neapolitan-style pizzas using a small pizza oven, I use an Ooni brand like this one on Amazon.

Recent Posts